Showing posts with label bureucracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bureucracy. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Learning our lesson from another dam failure


The Jakarta Post (original link)

Berly Martawardaya , JAKARTA | Wed, 04/01/2009 11:08 AM | Opinion

In the still of the early morning last Friday, gushing water from what was the Situ Gintung dam swept away the community living beneath it. As of this writing, close to 100 people in the Cireundeu area have been found dead and more than another hundred are still missing. Indonesia is grief stricken.

How could this happen? This is the age of the Internet and instant communication. Current technology could alert us to an asteroid approaching Earth from a million kilometers away. But this tragedy occurred in Jakarta, not some faraway, hard to reach area.

Unlike the Aceh tsunami, we cannot blame God for this — only ourselves.

While there has been a movement to reform the legal legacy of the Dutch colonial administration, there has been little attention paid to conserving its physical legacy, except for when potential tourist dollars are at stake.

Realizing the potential and peril of the Pesanggarahan River; in 1932 the Dutch built a dam to hold 2.1 million cubic meters of water in a 23-hectare area. Since then, many trees have been cut down and floods are more frequent; it seems that the Indonesian government has not done much to improve the dam.

We could not help but be saddened by reports that the foundations of the dam were weakened as surrounding communities salvaged building materials. This proved to be a very costly act of vandalism indeed.

Nevertheless, the government is not off the hook, ultimate responsibly for maintenance and preservations of public facilities lies with them. The all too frequent sinking of passenger ships and crumbling of bridges should be seen in same light; insufficient maintenance is to blame.
So what needs to be done?

First, the government needs to allocate funds from the Rp 17 trillion (US$1.5 billion) budget intended for infrastructure repair as part of a recent stimulus package for a comprehensive assessment of the country’s infrastructure. Bridges, dams and ships should be the priority, as they have the greatest potential for casualties.

The assessment of existing facilities, preferably by independent specialists, will not be as exciting and glamorous as establishing new ones is. No public ribbon cutting ceremonies with glitzy media coverage (not to mention, there would be less of a chance to embezzle funds) - just the nuts and bolts of governing for the people.

The rebuilding and rehabilitation of public infrastructure would be a massive, labor-intensive undertaking that would channel money to low-income people. High-income groups would too benefit from the high impact improved infrastructure would have on the national economy. We could also reallocate some Rp 56.3 trillion in tax-cuts of the stimulus to strengthen existing infrastructure.

Second, we need a thorough assessment of buildings located nearby rivers and other natural reserves. Bodies of water need clean areas around them to properly absorb water, and building on these areas can have disastrous consequences.

The harder part will be to assess the impact of legal but environmentally damaging construction. Teams of experts should follow rivers and other flood-prone areas to determine whether the establishment of water reservoirs is necessary. Don’t let the poor suffer to satisfy a few people’s greed.

New measures to transform the few remaining lakes and swamps into urban real estate should be resisted. Mother Nature is hurting and its time we listened to her.

The third measure should be an intensive public education campaign. The people should be made aware that the weakening of public facilities can endanger everyone’s life.

As direct beneficiaries, nearby communities should be fervent protectors. A clear line of reporting needs to be established, so the people know what to do if a crack or splinter in public infrastructure is spotted.

Some form of reward and encouragement for this potentially life saving measure needs to be established. Meanwhile, we need stern punishment for the vandals .


The writer is a lecturer at FEUI and PhD candidate in Economics at the University of Siena-Italy and a member of the NU Professional Circle

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Where have all the businessmen gone?


Jakarta Post (original link)

Berly Martawardaya , Jakarta | Tue, 02/10/2009 2:40 PM | Opinion

Why is there so much fuss about, mostly, small companies in the midst of the global financial crisis? Shouldn't we focus on rescuing big companies that employ a large number of people?

A national economy is like a human body; to remain healthy it needs to get rid of old and dying cells and replace them with a new and vigorous business entity. In the best cases, life support would be better than revitalization. In the worst cases, aging cells could turn into a cancer that would weaken and suck energy from the whole body.

In the globalized world, capital can be obtained from banks or investors; production can be outsourced to China; administration can be done in India. But the largest part of the profit goes to the brand owner who focuses on product development and marketing.

Compare top American companies from the last decade to today; Google, Starbucks were not even on the list last decade, while the financial behemoths such as Bear Sterns, Lehman Brothers and Merrill Lynch no longer exist as independent entities today.

Do the same for Indonesia and, except for few who went bankrupt during the Asian crisis, the list today is almost identical to the last decade, with family-base conglomerates, albeit more streamlined, remaining on top of the game.

A global entrepreneurship study by Klapper and Delgado from the World Bank for the period 2003-5 covered 83 countries and concluded that Indonesia is in the group with the lowest entry rate for new industrial companies.

Eurobaromater, a major public opinion survey in the EU's 25 member countries, found in 2007 that 45 percent of Europeans would like to become their own boss. The figure is even higher for young people (15 - 24 years old). The corresponding numbers in the US are 61 percent and 42 percent.

Some would blame Indonesia's feudalistic culture and history, which indeed may play some role, but other changeable and impermanent factors are likely to be in play.

What if someone told you that to start a business it takes two and half months and a total cost of nine months of the average Indonesian's income?

The rational choice is to only start a business when you are sure that you will get a sustained high return, unless you have a way to get around the lengthy and costly procedures.

Thus, the entrepreneur option in Indonesia is heavily skewed toward the rich and highly connected. A deeper look at the National Labor Force Survey (Sakernas) revealed that on average, only an entrepreneur with tertiary education earned a more than average income.

Indonesia is ranked 129th among 181 countries surveyed on the aforementioned survey, on the ease of doing business. The government needs to reduce red tape and complicated bureaucracy.

Ha Joon Chang, the Korean-born economist from Cambridge pointed out in The East Asian Development Experience (2006) that the key to East Asia's achievement is selective government intervention and domestic protection to prepare local companies to compete globally. Large countries should not coddle its major industries with firewalls of protection, since doing so only leads to those companies growing lazy and focusing on milking the domestic market.

We need to look to neighboring Malaysia, where it takes only 13 days to start a business costing less than two months of a Malaysian's average income. They have even had a cabinet level ministry for entrepreneurs since 2004.

Indonesia is behind Malaysia because of using a small country strategy in a large country setting. We need a comprehensive package of financial support, skills training and export assistance for would-be entrepreneurs.

Let's do things right this time and let (at least) a thousand entrepreneurs bloom.